Mistaken Identity Rule Leads to Embolo’s Dismissal
Switzerland forward Breel Embolo was sent off during his country’s World Cup 2026 quarter-final match against Argentina, becoming the first player to be dismissed under the new mistaken identity rule introduced for the tournament. The incident occurred in the 72nd minute, shortly after Switzerland had equalised to make the score 1-1.
Initially, referee Joao Pinheiro issued a yellow card to Argentina’s Leandro Paredes for what appeared to be a clumsy challenge on Embolo. However, the video assistant referee (VAR) intervened, prompting Pinheiro to review the play on the monitor.
Upon review, officials determined that Embolo had simulated a foul, falling before any contact was made by Paredes. As Embolo had already received a yellow card earlier in the match, the second yellow for simulation resulted in a red card, forcing Switzerland to play with ten men.
Impact on the Match and Swiss Reaction
The red card significantly altered the momentum of the match. Embolo, who plays for French club Rennes, was visibly distraught, leaving the pitch in Kansas City in tears and being consoled by his teammates. Swiss coach Murat Yakin expressed strong disapproval of the decision, stating, “There was definitely no reason to award a yellow card. It was a harmless situation. He should have let play continue.”
Yakin further criticised the rule, adding, “We were punished because of a rule that is unacceptable. I don’t understand it. The fact that they intervened unnecessarily is extremely hurtful. It’s a rule that has nothing to do with football. It destroyed our game. We have to accept it, but it is painful to lose that way.”
Despite the coach’s strong words, some pundits offered limited sympathy for Embolo. Former Major League Soccer striker Bradley Wright-Phillips commented, “I feel for Embolo’s team-mates, I don’t feel for him. He has cost his team maybe getting through to the semi-finals.” Former Jamaica international Jobi McAnuff added that Embolo “let himself down, he let his team-mates down.”
With Switzerland reduced to ten men, Argentina capitalised on their numerical advantage. Julian Alvarez scored in the 112th minute, followed by a goal from Lautaro Martinez in stoppage time of extra time, securing a 3-1 victory for Argentina. Alexis Mac Allister had initially given Argentina the lead from a Lionel Messi corner, before Dan Ndoye equalised for Switzerland in the second half.
Understanding the New Mistaken Identity Protocol
The decision to send off Embolo was made possible by FIFA’s new mistaken identity protocol, a rule change introduced for the tournament. This rule allows VAR to intervene if a player is booked or sent off, but the foul was actually committed by the opposition team, or if the wrong player was penalised.
The rule specifies that if an official penalises an offence but clearly misidentifies the player who committed it, only the identity of the attacker can be reviewed. In this instance, the initial yellow card to Paredes for the challenge on Embolo triggered the VAR review. Had Paredes not been booked, the mistaken identity ruling would not have been applicable, and Embolo would have remained on the field.
This marked only the second time in FIFA World Cup history that this specific protocol was used to overturn a yellow card decision. The first instance occurred earlier in the tournament when USA defender Tim Ream was initially booked for a foul on Miguel Almiron, but VAR review led to the caution being rescinded for Ream and instead issued to Almiron for simulation.
Embolo’s red card also made him the fourth player in the last 60 years to receive a second yellow card for simulation at a World Cup. The other players to have done so were Luis Pérez for Mexico against Portugal in 2006, Asamoah Gyan for Ghana against Brazil in 2006, and Francesco Totti for Italy against South Korea in 2002.
Argentina will now face England in the semi-finals.
Read Also
Source: bbc.com
Arjun Sharma
Sports Reporter